RELATED: Evil Dead The Game: Best Demon Warlord Build
However, they are all quite different, and in these differences emerge some strengths and weaknesses. On occasion, the strengths are powerful enough to make up for any weaknesses. For other survivors, their weaknesses are so glaring that they can single-handedly be the reason the team goes down in any given Evil Dead: The Game match.
Updated on December 4th, 2022 by Hodey Johns: This list needed to be updated for two major reasons. Unlike some live service games that get a tweak here or there, this game has had some movies overhauled entirely. Some characters play dramatically better or worse than before as a result. Also, two new survivors, Lia and David Allen, have entered the fray with some DLC and needed to be ranked as well. Team compositions and personal experience may make players feel differently about where the survivors rank on this list. but looking at some game statistics, it’s clear that some survivors have a tendency to land at the top of the charts while others are struggling to find a win at all.
15 Scotty
Scotty is just horribly optimized and even ideal warrior skills can’t save him. He’s incentivized to use heavy attacks, making him more vulnerable to damage from nearby deadites. This is only negative if he uses a lumberjack axe, but that’s not the right weapon to be used with predominantly heavy attacks. Taking more damage and doing less damage not only makes him a bad warrior but also makes him the worst survivor around.
14 David Allen
A support hero with no extra healing capabilities is a tough sell. Players may want to replay this horror game again, but if they want to support, try a different survivor. David Allen is good against fear-based assailants, but that’s usually a role that the leaders do better in.
When playing against an inexperienced demon user, David can potentially have some success if the user doesn’t know that David is good against possessed units. But an experienced gamer knows they can just switch tactics. Without a valid healer, the damage dealt will be all the more powerful against David’s squad.
13 Kelly Maxwell
Here is Kelly, a hunter, who is incentivized to do melee damage and rotate it with her ranged capabilities. Excusing the fact that she’s not taking advantage of her class bonuses by doing this, she also needs way more help than this to be an effective melee combatant. With the right hunter skills, she can become competent in melee combat, especially in longer fights, but she still won’t be as good as an average warrior, plus she’s taking up the hunter spot on the team, crippling their badly-needed ranged capabilities.
12 Ash Williams (Evil Dead 2)
If it weren’t for his active ability, Ash Williams (Evil Dead 2) would likely be at the bottom of this list. The active ability can knock enemy demons out of their possessions quicker by draining their infernal energy, but the team would probably prefer raw damage from their hunter. And, bad news, he’s not good on that front. He’s essentially locked into using a double-barrel, which is not anywhere close to as good as the standard shotgun.
11 Mia Allen
When it comes to great games with a B-Movie setting, this one is there and new DLC character Mia Allen contributes to the theme. However, she’s got some large drawbacks. She’s incentivized to get her fear meter high. To avoid getting possessed, she requires an active ability to stop it. But the kicker is that she’ll be almost assuredly possessed afterward unless she killed loads of enemies during the sequence. That means, on a good team, the hunter will outkill her and get her possessed unless they back off on damage.
10 Pablo Simon Bolivar
Pablo is the lowest of the support heroes due to his over-reliance on amulet healing. The others have massive healing on shorter cooldowns while Pablo is stuck giving out amulets on massive two-minute cooldowns. It’s better than no support hero and he’s definitely more of a difference-maker than the survivors lower down on this list, but everybody on the team will be wishing the player using him had selected a better option.
RELATED: Evil Dead The Game: Best Demon Puppeteer Build
Pablo has been slightly buffed but it’s hard to tell; he’s gained powers that transfer to his team when he uses the amulet himself. But that’s part of the issue, he has to be the one using the amulets and not the teammate who might be in need.
9 Lord Arthur
Overall, Lord Arthur is a good friend if the team is full of melee combatants. He’s a leader who boosts this damage. Optimize the leader skills and he’ll be alright so long as the rest of the team understands they need to drop any expectations for their ranged attackers.
Lord Arthur has risen on this list since the game’s release; his skills now increase all melee damage instead of just heavy attacks. However, he’s still somewhat capped by his effectiveness with exclusively melee weapons and, specifically, a sword.
8 Ash Williams (Army Of Darkness)
When it comes to solo play, Ash Williams (Army Of Darkness) would find himself much higher on this list. He’s got some built-in healing and support, buying himself some freedom from the reliance on support characters. He does need to get lucky and find some amulets for a sustained run and pray for a good chainsaw, but with a solid team around him, he’ll do fine up front.
7 Annie Knowby
Leaders act as secondary support and damage survivors and Annie plays the part well. She’s strictly all about ranged damage, so teams will need to coordinate, but when they do, they’ll be glad that she makes it worth the coordination. She’s not entirely useless for melee attackers, who will be happy to use their finishers more often when she’s in the squad.
6 Amanda Fisher
Despite a heavy reliance on pistols, Amanda finds herself in an above-average position on this list. She can shoot for a brief time without using ammunition, a handy tool when supplies run low in longer battles. She really shines against boss summons as her consecutive hits increase her damage. A marksman who never misses will find her damage threshold is non-existent, they just have to be careful not to lose the buff with a miss.
5 Henry The Red
Henry the Red is the best warrior in the game due to his unique design of being the only character capable of weathering hits and returning damage to his opponents. He’s also free of the restraints that would make him rely on a single melee weapon; he’s encouraged to use the best available and hop into combat. Demons will hate his nearly-limitless survivability.
RELATED: Evil Dead The Game: Best Demon Necromancer Build
Henry the Red had a slight nerf in that he now requires a shield to reflect damage. He’s still the best warrior and tank, but players will have to be cautious to make sure that extra shield doesn’t fall.
4 Ash Williams (Ash Vs Evil Dead)
When it comes to ranking the leaders, Ash Williams (Ash Vs Evil Dead) has a solid spot at the top of his class. The others force teams to choose between melee or ranged damage while Ash gives a boost to all sources. He helps support his team by reducing fear and has a nice incentive to play on the frontlines to help his melee companions.
3 Cheryl Williams
Cheryl is the most classic of all the support units in that she’s a bona fide healer. Her active ability has a moderate cooldown but it is good enough to take most teams to full health every minute and a half, greatly reducing the effectiveness of demons trying to win by a war of attrition. Of course, supports heal their teams primarily with Shemp’s Colas, and nobody does it better than Cheryl.
2 Ed Getley
The flashlight bonuses are a bit quirky, but they do serve to completely erase the chance demons have of successfully springing a trap on the team. That’s not the end of his support assistance as a hunter; The Collector keeps the team full on Shemp’s Colas, ammo, and amulets while also giving his team better weapons. He’s admittedly support-heavy but deals more than enough damage to make him the best hunter around.
1 Ash Williams (The Evil Dead)
Finally, Ash Williams (The Evil Dead) is not just the best support survivor, he’s the best character in the game. Being great with him does require some situational awareness. His heavy melee attacks heal as do his headshots. Lifesteal means he can heal without any Shemp’s Colas and without relying on long cooldowns. His active ability removes fear as a factor in the game. By removing one avenue for a demon victory and severely pushing back against the other, even a bad team will find an easy win with Ash supporting them.
He was already ranked as the best survivor when the game debuted and, incredibly, he’s been buffed. It used to be that teammates needed to perform successive headshots, keeping this support hero from wanting to get any killing blows. Now, he’s free to do this killing on his own and still receive the benefits.
Evil Dead: The Game was released on May 13th, 2022, and is available on PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Nintendo Switch, and PC.
MORE: Evil Dead The Game: Every Demon, Ranked
